Dumplin’ by Julie Murphy

18304322Published: September 15th, 2015

by: Balzer + Bray

Genres: YA, Contemporary

Format: ebook

Source: Library

My Rating: 2.5 Stars

Add To Goodreads

Self-proclaimed fat girl Willowdean Dickson (dubbed “Dumplin’” by her former beauty queen mom) has always been at home in her own skin. Her thoughts on having the ultimate bikini body? Put a bikini on your body. With her all-American beauty best friend, Ellen, by her side, things have always worked…until Will takes a job at Harpy’s, the local fast-food joint. There she meets Private School Bo, a hot former jock. Will isn’t surprised to find herself attracted to Bo. But she is surprised when he seems to like her back.

Instead of finding new heights of self-assurance in her relationship with Bo, Will starts to doubt herself. So she sets out to take back her confidence by doing the most horrifying thing she can imagine: entering the Miss Clover City beauty pageant—along with several other unlikely candidates—to show the world that she deserves to be up there as much as any twiggy girl does. Along the way, she’ll shock the hell out of Clover City—and maybe herself most of all.

With starry Texas nights, red candy suckers, Dolly Parton songs, and a wildly unforgettable heroine—Dumplin’ is guaranteed to steal your heart.

 

My Thoughts

two-half-stars

After months of wanting to devour this book, I was let down by the “forgettable” heroine, Willowdean. She may be unforgettable to some, but she is just another YA heroine navigating the halls of high school. Sure, she’s not your typical skinny girl, but that is all that sets her apart from the rest. She’s insecure half the time, trying to juggle two guys at once, and despite the taunts that she receives about her weight, she has a tendency to think negative thoughts about others who are “fatter” than her, or has something that makes them the target for bullies. I was awed by her boldness to actually fall out with her best friend because she decided to enter the pageant. 

Dumplin’ is not at all what I thought it to be. Sure, it has it’s moments, but those weren’t enough for me to say, Now this is the greatest YA contemporary I’ve ever read. I wanted to be in the moment with Willowdean while she embraced her curves and shut down stereotypical ideas that you have to be a size 1 to win a pageant. In some ways, I can see how readers love this book. It’s on the right track to bringing “real” characters to the forefront of the YA genre that usually center around Little Miss Perfect. That’s about all that stood out to me. The rest was just like all the other books I’ve read. The love triangle was not needed (nor wanted), and it took over the whole plot. 

Willowdean was doing good at the beginning of this book. She and her best friend El were as thick as thieves. They hung out, shared secrets, went swimming, and sang Dolly Parton songs at the top of their lungs. And then the shift. El starts hanging out with Callie. Willowdean immediately hates her, as she feels that Callie is taking her best friend. Then she and her coworker Bo kiss. Everything is fine until Bo touches her sides. It was like she didn’t even know she was a big girl until that moment. I wanted her confidence to extend to her finally getting a guy. A hot guy. But no, she was so worried about what others would think. Add to that, she’s still grieving for her aunt Lucy, and it all just went downhill from there.

Entering the pageant was like the defining moment. Well, at least I thought it was. Not only does Willow enter, but so does Millie (a girl who is bigger than Willow – and we wouldn’t have known that if Willow hadn’t given us that bit with her hypocritical monologue), and 2 other girls who don’t fit what society thinks a beauty pageant contestant should look like. Sadly, this didn’t deliver. The pageant didn’t happen until the end, but I wanted to watch these girls get into action. I wanted them to be fierce and show all of Texas that they have what it takes. What I got instead was Willow wallowing because she doesn’t have her best friend anymore, more wallowing because she can’t choose between Bo and Mitch, and her constantly arguing with her mother about her weight. If Willow was so happy and comfortable in her skin, she didn’t act like it. The only time I got that impression was at the beginning when she went swimming. Sure, she braved the swimsuit portion of the pageant, but that fearlessness was gone by then.

I give this 2.5 for effort. It was brave to take on a character like Willow when everyone is so used to cookie cutter girls. Instead of making Willow stand out, the author just made her like all the other YA heroines before her. Murphy gives us two “fat” girls, a lesbian, a girl who needs corrective shoes, and a drag queen. Do you know how epic this book could have been? Am I the only one seeing the potential here? This was a big let down. I’m not sure I even want to recommend this one. 

Advertisements

34 thoughts on “Dumplin’ by Julie Murphy

  1. OMigoshhhh this sounds SO. DISAPPOINTING. I stayed away from this book ever since hearing Willow’s monologue in the beginning about big girls. This sounds pretty much no different than the NUMEROUS contemporaries out there, sigh. And the whole juggling two guys thing makes me want to frown, lol. I’m so sorry you didn’t enjoy this as much as it was hyped up to be, Lekeisha.

    Like

  2. GIRLLL yas to this review! I’ve seen only a few negative reviews on this, and all of them mentioned some of the same things you had a problem with! I was never really interested in picking this up anyway, but I just wanted to know if it was as ” important ” as everyone said it was. Glad to see that me passing it up didn’t cause me to miss out on anything.

    Like

  3. I really wish that YA authors would let go of the love triangle thing. I hate it when they wedge it into a story where it’s completely unnecessary. This one does sound like it had a lot of potential. Too bad it didn’t live up to it, it sounded pretty interesting.

    Like

  4. “Sure, she isn’t your normal ‘skinny’ girl, but that’s all that sets her apart’… that sounds very disappointing, Lekeisha! The summary made her sound very take charge and sure of herself. And self-doubt is part of being a teen, which is why it would have been very refreshing to have a heroine who is unconventional both when it comes to looks and self confidence. Sorry this didn’t work for you!

    Like

    • Yes, self doubt is a part of every teen, and I really get that. But this promised so much more, but it turns out to be just another YA love story. “Go big or go home” seems like the wrong phrase for this story.

      Like

  5. When I heard about this book, I loved the sound of the premise. I’ve been waiting so long for a blogger I follow to review this, and I’m disappointed to hear that it wasn’t as good as expected. YA contemporary isn’t my genre so I doubt I would have picked this up anyway, but it’s still a shame to hear that it didn’t work for you, and your tastes and mine usually align pretty well. Ah well, hope next book is better!

    Like

  6. I’m so sorry this was a disappointment — I’ve been wanting to read this one too and have heard such rave reviews! That is annoying that the heroine didn’t meet your expectations. Great review, though!!

    Like

  7. I enjoyed this more than you did but agree that I would have preferred this book without the romance and more as a story about self-acceptance and friendship. But I hope the positive responses to this book serves to encourage authors to write stories about non-traditional heroines!
    Thanks so much for stopping by! Jen @ YA Romantics

    Like

  8. You said the not-so magic words- love triangle. Ugh!

    I was interested in this one to see a curvy girl go for it. Oh well! I would still try, but I know myself. I have no patience with the triangles.

    Nice review, Lekeisha!

    Like

  9. Well I’m sorry this wasn’t as good as you were hoping it would be and I’m going to have to pass on this one. I really don’t think I could read a book about a plus size girl thinking negatively about bigger girls. I have a really big problem with how some women put other women down in general or when trying to feel better about themselves. This won’t be for me and thanks for the honest review!

    Like

  10. I have been excited to read this book. But among the raving reviews I have also seen quite a lot of people who were sorely disappointed by this book and that makes me a bit more nervous about it. I don’t think this is one I am going to really enjoy it. To be honest, it sort of sounds like any other book!

    Like

    • I am looking forward to reading your review. If you put this up against other books in the genre, it’s an okay read. But this character is not confident as all the rave reviews claim. I am just mad that it let me down. You may love this book!

      Liked by 1 person

  11. I was let down by the hype as well. The romance was just so confusing. I didn’t understand why she freaked out about Bo either. It’s like some part of her brain turned on saying, “wait a minute! You’re supposed to be self conscious!” And her problem with Callie was so cliche.

    Like

  12. Aww! 😦 I’m sorry you didn’t love this one, Lekeisha, but I understand where you’re coming from. As a fat girl myself I was able to connect with Willow, but I’ll admit that some of her decisions/things she said were a bit problematic.
    Great review!

    Like

I love comments, and try to reply as often as I can. Know that I read each and every one.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s