A Million Times Goodnight by Kristina McBride

22300826 (1)Published: July 28th 2015 By: Egmont USA

Genres: Young-Adult, Contemporary, Mystery, Thriller

Format: eARC Source: Netgalley My Rating: 3 Stars

Find It: Goodreads || Amazon

A teen Sliding Doors. One choice creates parallel dual narratives in this romantic contemporary mystery-thriller perfect for fans of Just Like Fate and Pivot Point.

One Night. Two Paths. Infinite Danger.

On the night of the big Spring Break party, Hadley “borrows” her boyfriend Ben’s car without telling him. As payback, he posts a naked picture of her online for the entire senior class to see.

Now Hadley has a choice: go back to the party and force Ben to delete the picture or raise the stakes and take his beloved car on a road trip as far away from their hometown of Oak Grove, Ohio, as she can get.

Chapters alternate to reveal each possible future as Hadley, her ex-boyfriend, Josh, and her best friends embark on a night of reckless adventure where old feelings are rekindled, friendships are tested, and secrets are uncovered that are so much worse than a scandalous photo.


This one is hard to review, simply because it was confusing at times. I don’t think that the dual parallel narratives were needed for this story. Since everything revolved around the photo, the plot would have been so much better had it stuck to one scenario. There are some parts that made me want to know more, but at the end, I still felt like this could have been written so differently.

Hadley and her two best friends embark on a little tribute detour to reminisce about their friend Penny, who died the year before in an accident. Hadley, forgot to mention that she didn’t exactly ask her boyfriend Ben for his car, she just took the keys. In his need for revenge, he posts a naked picture of her on Facebook. The other side to this complicated story is Josh, Hadley’s ex-boyfriend. He’s the pariah now, and the reason that Penny is dead. Everyone at school hates him, and even Hadley herself has ignored him all year. Hadley thinks that showing up with Josh in Ben’s car is the perfect revenge. Only, we get two scenarios about the outcome of this decision. In both cases, Josh’s life is threatened for even being on sight. Hadley, is hiding something from everyone and the naked photo causes all kinds of things to come to light.

I can’t say that I like Hadley all that much. She is so quick to make dumb decisions that made no sense. Ben is a dirt bag, and needs a swift kick to the groin. Brooklyn, Hadley – they were all just a group of vapid characters that made poor choices and drank too much. I was more keen on finding out what Josh did the night of the accident that caused Penny’s death, and why everyone was out to get him. There’s some drugging and a lot of other illegal activities going on here, so if that isn’t your thing, stay away. I just don’t get the point of the parallel narratives. Was it meant to make this more interesting? Well, it didn’t for me. I’m conflicted about recommending this one, but then again, this whole setup may just work for you. It’s not the worst story I’ve read, just the most confusing.


10 thoughts on “A Million Times Goodnight by Kristina McBride

  1. It seems like you would have rathered that the focus of the book would have been on Josh instead of the other two characters who seemed kind of immature and like they never really did anything smart, which is a shame. Sorry that the dual situations didn’t really work for this novel. I don’t think I will be picking this one up :/


  2. I think the story might be interesting to me but how it was done might not so much. It sounds like maybe it’s a little too confusing. Too convoluted in it’s execution. I hadn’t heard of this before though so thanks for the review!


  3. Great review! I hate it when a book leaves me confused. I have read books where the dual narratives really add to story but in a lot of cases it just doesn’t work. I hate it when I really like one character’s voice and the book keeps moving to an alternate character. Sorry this one didn’t live up to your expectations.


I love comments, and try to reply as often as I can. Know that I read each and every one.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s